Tribunals must assess all evidence

April 28, 2026 · WOWERI

The UK Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal by a Pakistani man who claimed asylum in the UK. The court held that the First-tier Tribunal was wrong to allow his appeal.

Important UK Court of Appeal Decision

The UK Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal by a Pakistani man who claimed asylum in the UK on the basis that he would face persecution as a gay man in Pakistan. The court held that the First-tier Tribunal was wrong to allow his appeal simply because the Home Office presenting officer did not challenge the core issue in cross-examination. The court emphasized that the tribunal is required to assess all evidence, even if the core issue is not challenged in cross-examination. This decision has significant implications for individuals seeking asylum in the UK.

What this means for you

If you are seeking asylum in the UK, this decision highlights the importance of thoroughly preparing your case. You must provide all relevant evidence in support of your claim and be prepared to answer questions in cross-examination.

Source: freemovement.org.uk